Trick AND Treats at Warren and Annabelle’s Dinner Show

At Warren and Annabelle’s, Lahaina, Maui, the stage is set for trickery the moment you arrive. After checking in, you and friends will be escorted into a “waiting room.” There you find yourself befuddled by a riddle that must be solved before you go any further – which only makes your entry into the haute saloon parlor, chamber of resident ghost Annabelle, all the more appealing!

While Annabelle plays your favorite tunes and song requests, guests are invited to relax with pupus and drinks from Warren and Annabelle’s carefully selected menu. Show-goers can order ala carte from the menu or dine as part of a dinner show package known as the Royal Flush.

In addition to show admission, the Royal Flush package includes a combination platter of Gourmet Appetizers served to each guest including: Spicy Crab Cake with sweet chili plum sauce, Coconut Battered Shrimps with a ponzu dipping sauce, Polynesian Chicken Satay with tropical plum sauce, and a Savory Kalua Pork Wrap with Maui pineapple salsa. Guests also receive dessert, either Crème Brulee, White Chocolate Raspberry Cheesecake, Key Lime Pie, Hot Apple Pie A La Mode, Classic New York-Style Cheesecake or Chocolate Pots de Crème (see the recipe below!) Additionally, the Royal Flush includes two premium cocktails, specialty drinks, blended drinks, imported and domestic beers, house wines, well drinks, and/or Soft Drinks (gratuity included). It’s a great deal at $94.50, cnosidering show admission is $56.00 per person.

The great food and drinks served at Warren and Annabelle’s are appropriate preparation for the belly laughs you’ll enjoy once summoned into the cozy theater where Warren performs sleight of hand with flawless precision, immense wit, and perfect comedic timing. At each performance four couples are chosen to sit in the coveted “hot seats,” assuring each show proffers a different dynamic and off the cuff humor.

The magic tricks are astounding; but it is Warren’s showmanship and personality that keeps the house packed week after week, year after year. If you’ve never experienced this show, one of Maui’s true entertainment jewels, you owe it to yourself to attend. If you’ve seen Warren time and again, you already realize that great comedy never gets old, and watching Warren in action is always a new delight.